So we have something like 100+ spec houses for sale and are moving through them at a pace that should exhaust supply in five or six years. These houses were mostly built using commercial loans, with personal guarantees signed by the principals. It seems obvious to some of us that a lot of these projects are in trouble, won’t sell for what the builder needs even to break even and will eventually result in default, reversion of title to the lender and a personal judgment against the guarantors. So wouldn’t a builder jump at the chance to bail out and walk away owing nothing?
In short, no. Builders are incurable optimists – that’s how they became spec builders in the first place- and they seem convinced that, all evidence to the contrary, if they can just hang on, maybe for as little as six months, there’s is the house that will sell at a fat profit. It’s the other guys who are going down.
We have approached agents for a number of such builders, and offered to get their clients out owing nothing. So far, no takers, even as some of these guys lose their projects to the bank, even though loans are no longer being rolled over, even though doomsday approaches. So okay, we’ll deal with the banks later. Eventually, all these homes will find buyers. I have no confidence that any of them, will sell for a price that makes the builder whole but denial is a powerful force, one that trumps logic, every time.
UPDATE: A skeptical reader quite justifiably questioned my figure of “100+ spec houses” and asked whether that included condo’s. That’s an understandable question but no, we have 104 houses listed built in 2007 or later all of which, or almost all – I did a quick skim – are specs and vacant. The reader also suggested that there were some well priced houses mixed in with these projects but again, doing a quick skim, I disagree. Nothing looks to my eye as though it will sell for even close to current asking price, notwithstanding that some of these have already taken multi-million dollar price cuts. The low priced end – Havemeyer Lane, for instance, or McCarthur, are looking for $1.5ish long past the day when that level could be attained in that neighborhood. And of the 72 houses priced over $3 million, good luck to all.






