I attended the open house at 122 Old Church Road today with high expectations but was disappointed. I wanted to like this house because the owners restored the old mansion rather than tear it down and notwithstanding its $10.750 price tag, I’d hoped it would sell quickly as a reward for them showing such restraint in this time of tear – downs. But I don’t think it will.
It seems like a work still in progress – the owners addressed all the important mechanical issues but either ran out of money or got tired of the process; they’ve gotten half-way through and pulled the plug. Which would be fine, except for that price. Original drafty windows don’t make it at this price range, even if they’ve had ’60′s Sears Roebuck aluminum combination screens/storm windows slapped on their exterior. Thin marble countertops in the baths look cheap, not elegant and an acrylic whirlpool tub in the master bath just feels wrong. If this house was originally built with substandard crown moldings, that error should have been corrected now, but wasn’t (I suspect there were once beautiful moldings here but were replaced sometime during a 1950′s renovation to impart a “contemporary” feel. Bad move.
There are wetlands – who knew? – smack in the middle of the back yard, preventing its use as a site for a pool house or anything like that and long ago a previous owner sold off a front lot, thereby screwing up the access width and route. You can’t blame either of these flaws on the present owners but they don’t help.
So all that’s just my impression and maybe someone with far more money than me will like this place exactly as it is. I personally think the renovators grossly overpaid for the property ($5 million plus) back in 2010 and will have a hard time recovering what they’ve put in.