No, the headline should read, “How seven minutes saved taxpayers from a multi-million-dollar fraud”

Take the slow route to the morgue

Take the slow route to the morgue

How seven minutes could cost NY trooper’s widow millions

On Dec. 7, 2009, New York State Police narcotics investigator Richard O’Brien fell off a ladder while fixing his mother’s roof.

He lived for only three more hours after the fall — but in that brief time, fellow troopers tried to have him retired on disability.

Now, Stephanie O’Brien, his widow, is fighting in court, saying a faulty fax machine and a measly seven minutes mean she and the couple’s daughter would get a $342,000 death payout — rather than lifetime benefits that could total in the millions.

Fellow troopers rushed to the emergency room at St. Luke’s Cornwall Hospital in Newburgh, where O’Brien, 42, lay mortally injured and unconscious following his off-duty repair accident at 3:34 p.m. They immediately asked State Police Headquarters in Albany to send retirement forms — though it took the ER’s faulty fax machine several tries to receive them, causing the first in a series of delays.

The troopers helped O’Brien’s wife fill them out.

The form she signed checked off a payment option in which Richard would get 75 percent of his $90,000 salary for life. If he died, his beneficiary, Stephanie, would receive the same $67,500-a-year for life.

It then took 10 tries — an 18-minute delay — to fax the papers back to a State Police supervisor, who finally received them at 6:19 p.m.The supervisor took 11 minutes to review the application and formally file it by fax to state Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli at 6:31 p.m.

Meanwhile, O’Brien had died at 6:24 p.m.

At that point, the 14-year police veteran became ineligible for retirement. The state Comptroller’s Office offered Stephanie a death benefit — three times O’Brien’s last 12 months of pay. But the disability benefits could have amounted to much more — $3.3 million if Stephanie, now 36, lives to age 86.

Of course it’s a sad story, and it’s understandable that his fellow cops would want to help his widow and child, but in any other circumstance this would be fraud, and prosecutors would be involved. Unless, of course, it happened in Greenwich’s civil service ranks, where this goes on all the time.


Filed under Uncategorized

8 responses to “No, the headline should read, “How seven minutes saved taxpayers from a multi-million-dollar fraud”

  1. Anonymous

    Fraud is an understatement! Disgusting!

  2. Mickster

    War veteran and cop that we all are indebted to BUT this IS gaming the system big time.

    Why should I pay millions for an off-duty accident?

    Makes you wonder how often this is done successfully around the country.

  3. Al Dente

    With a government employee, how can you discern between living and dead?

  4. Mavis Davis

    The widow trying to game the system was married to the man for just 5 months.

  5. John M

    Does anybody else find it unusual that a 42 year old with 14 years of public service can retire with a payout of 75% of salary?

  6. Peg

    Here is a site that tracks all public salaries in California. If you return to the home site, you can view all pensions, too.

    Anyone wonder why some of our states are going belly up?

    Anyone? Anyone?